HomeGovernanceRae Lindsay: bringing human rights into commercial legal practice

Rae Lindsay: bringing human rights into commercial legal practice

Clifford Chance partner Rae Lindsay discusses human rights advice, conflict zones and corporate liability ahead of the Business and Human Rights Lawyers Association’s February conference.

Commercial lawyers can help companies translate commitments to respect human rights into decisions about investments, business relationships and day-to-day operations. For Rae Lindsay, that requires understanding both the legal risks facing a business and the consequences of its activities for people – and helping clients address the two consistently.

That connection has shaped her practice and her involvement in establishing the Business and Human Rights Lawyers Association (BHRLA), which she co-chairs. Ahead of its February conference, Lindsay describes a continuing need to embed human rights considerations across commercial practice, from corporate governance and transactions to investigations, disputes and remedies.

The challenge extends beyond interpreting legislation with a human rights label. Companies may also be seeking to fulfil commitments under the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs), whose expectations do not necessarily coincide with the boundaries of legal obligation or liability. Understanding how those frameworks interact is central to the advice lawyers can provide.

A shared professional challenge

Lindsay’s interest developed through her background in public international law and involvement in human rights-related litigation around 25 years ago. International legal obligations largely attach to states, prompting questions about how companies fitted into that framework. She subsequently participated in the process led by John Ruggie that produced the UNGPs, endorsed in 2011.

Ruggie’s framework brought together state duties, corporate responsibilities and access to remedy. Lindsay recalls his recognition of the influence commercial lawyers could have on how businesses approached opportunities and risks. Her involvement in that work left her with a strong sense of responsibility to help carry the UNGPs’ ideas into legal practice.

“What I’ve always loved about this area is the collaboration,” she says. “There’s a shared understanding of what the UNGPs are trying to achieve and the importance of making them part of legal practice.”

Subsequent work through a law firm peer-learning project explored what the principles meant for firms themselves, as businesses, and for their client advice. The BHRLA grew out of that experience, alongside a sense that the issues were not translating sufficiently into changes in practice.

Firms were developing expertise separately while confronting many of the same questions. Lindsay saw an opportunity to share learning and extend understanding beyond specialist teams. Legal education is another area where she sees room for improvement.

“There’s still a gap in how human rights are taught and how their relevance to commercial legal practice is explained,” she says.

The relevance, she argues, extends across corporate governance, risk management, contracts, transactions and dispute resolution. Building that understanding across the profession is a central part of the BHRLA’s purpose.

Connecting responsibilities and legal risk

In Lindsay’s experience, clients have long sought advice on what policies aligned with the UNGPs mean in practice, particularly when difficult circumstances test those commitments. Lawyers need to explain the applicable legal requirements while helping clients understand what the broader responsibility to respect human rights entails.

These are related enquiries, but they are not interchangeable. Assessing potential liability to the company does not, by itself, answer every question about how its conduct affects people. Equally, pursuing a human rights objective requires an understanding of the legal obligations and risks arising along the way.

Lindsay acknowledges the criticism that lawyers can become preoccupied with identifying corporate exposure. Her account of their contribution is more constructive: understanding the boundaries can help clients find ways to pursue human rights objectives while managing legal risk.

“It’s about achieving human rights outcomes while understanding the legal risks,” she explains. “You’re trying to understand the risks to the company in a way that is consistent with managing the risks to people.”

That can require difficult judgements, particularly where internationally recognised rights are hard to respect in practice. The UNGPs provide a framework for approaching those decisions, rather than removing the need to make them.

Advising in conflict-affected areas

Conflict-affected areas bring these questions into particularly sharp focus. Lindsay describes growing demand for advice as human rights scrutiny, new legal requirements and difficult operating conditions converge. Differences between jurisdictions can add complexity to decisions already carrying substantial commercial and reputational consequences.

“Different parts of the world view these issues differently,” she says. “Helping clients deal with conflicting legal obligations is familiar territory for lawyers. Here, you also have to consider their responsibility to respect human rights.”

Her public international law background helps her examine the different layers involved: what international law says, how domestic legal obligations apply and how the responsibility to respect human rights interacts with both. Heightened human rights due diligence is receiving greater attention, alongside cases raising potential criminal exposure for companies in some jurisdictions.

The practical questions vary considerably. A company considering an investment in a difficult jurisdiction needs to assess whether and how to proceed. A business already operating somewhere that develops into a conflict zone may instead need urgent advice on a situation it did not anticipate.

“How do you do your best to respect human rights in places where that’s incredibly difficult?” Lindsay asks. “Often there’s no black and white answer. The UNGPs help you work through those judgements.”

Her practice therefore combines advising corporations, international organisations and state-owned entities on preventive risk management advice with investigations, potential claims and defending litigation when it cannot be avoided. When problems arise, the work can also involve considering how disputes might be resolved with the principles’ approach to remedy in mind.

Following liability developments

Lindsay also sees increasing attention to the potential accountability of financial institutions and others whose relationships with harmful activities are less direct. Such scrutiny is not new, she stresses, but efforts to develop legal theories and test their boundaries have become more pronounced.

For companies and their advisors, the task is to distinguish arguments being advanced from circumstances in which liability may ultimately arise. Developments differ between jurisdictions, and the significance of individual cases needs careful assessment.

“Litigation is gradually challenging some longstanding assumptions about where liability may arise,” she says. “Lawyers need to understand how those arguments develop, what they mean for accountability and when they could translate into legal liability risks.”

That reinforces the importance of prevention. Governance arrangements need to help businesses identify and mitigate risks before harm occurs, while recognising that claims may develop over many years.

Effective advice also requires collaboration. Lindsay describes working with in-house counsel, sustainability teams and human rights specialists, whose perspectives need to inform a consistent response. The range of disciplines involved requires coordination within law firms too.

“It’s a problem when teams within businesses and law firms work in isolation,” she says. “You have to bring them together.”

That practical challenge returns the discussion to the BHRLA’s purpose. Its conference on 2–3 February 2027 will address business and human rights in a changing geopolitical and technological landscape. For Lindsay, the underlying professional task remains connecting legal expertise with an understanding of what businesses are trying to achieve under the UNGPs – and making that understanding part of ordinary commercial advice.

To read more, subscribe to Forward Law Review

Already a subscriber? Log in here: